Take the 2-minute tour ×
German Language Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of German wanting to discuss the finer points of the language and translation. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In English, "to judge someone" often implies a negative opinion, as in "Don't judge me!".

Is there a German equivalent for this? How would you translate the example? My dictionary gives "jmdn. richten". Is this any good in this context?

share|improve this question

4 Answers 4

up vote 16 down vote accepted

I'd say "richten" is more a judicial term (btw not to confuse with "hinrichten" which means "to execute so."). This is what a judge does. I assume you mean "to judge so." in the sense of having prejudices against someone as in

You should not judge people by their appearance.

(from Merriam-Webster)

This would simply be "beurteilen nach":

Man sollte andere nicht nach ihrem Äußeren beurteilen.

I don't think there is a direct translation for "don't judge me" without adding an object as in the example above:

Beurteile mich nicht nach meinem Auto.

would be

Don't judge me by my car.

In some contexts you could probably use "verurteile mich nicht" but "verurteilen" means more like "to heavily criticize" and is usually for quite serious acts and causes others to keep their distance (apart from also being a synonym for "richten"). I think for most cases "beurteilen" should be fine.

share|improve this answer
1  
"Verurteilen" comes close to the negative sense of don't judge me - you can put it in a (rhethorical) question: "Wieso verurteilst Du mich jetzt deswegen?" –  Takkat Sep 25 '11 at 14:14
    
I don't know. I think "verurteilen" is way too harsh and makes "judging so." look rather neutral in comparison. –  musiKk Sep 25 '11 at 16:42
2  
I do agree. "Verurteilen" definitely is negative whereas "beurteilen" in the meaning of judging is not. By putting it in a question we can weaken this harshness. After all it depends much on context anyway ;) –  Takkat Sep 25 '11 at 17:32
    
"Richtet nicht, auf dass Ihr nicht gerichtet werden" aus dem Kopf aus die Bibel zitierend. Aber abgesehen von der Anspielung auf diese Bibelstelle wird man be- und verurteilen bevorzugen. –  user unknown Sep 25 '11 at 22:08
    
Die Verengung auf **Vor**urteile ist, soweit ich weiß, weder im engl., noch im Deutschen nötig. Man kann urteilen ohne dass man von Vorurteilen reden muss. –  user unknown May 29 '12 at 12:22

jemanden bewerten

is used like "to judge someone" in English

jemanden beurteilen

rather refers to grades and performance

jemanden verurteilen

to condemn or convict someone

jemanden richten

means to judge someone (in court) and has the connotation of "to enforce judgement"

share|improve this answer
    
'jemanden bewerten' klingt ungewohnt. Man bewertet eher Gegenstände, etc. Wie wärs mit messen: "Man muss ihn an seiner Leistung messen." –  Em1 May 29 '12 at 12:04
    
@Em1: Findest du? Meine spontane Antwort wäre jetzt auch "bewerten" gewesen, noch vor "be-/verurteilen". –  0x6d64 May 29 '12 at 12:59
    
@0x6d64 Eigentlich finde ich schlichtweg "urteilen" am besten (wie schon andere Antworten erwähnen). Ich würde das Prefix be- in dem Kontext nicht verwenden (du kannst aber meine Leistung beurteilen oder wie in einer Antwort genannt: wegen/aufgrund von z.b Aussehen beurteilen) und verurteilen solltest du mich nur, wenn ich was Dummes angestellt habe. Aber bewerten, wie gesagt, klingt merkwürdig. Kann man mit Sicherheit auch sagen, ähnlich dann wie "beurteilen", aber woran du jemanden bewertest sollte gegeben sein. –  Em1 May 29 '12 at 13:31

I would suggest a translation that hasn't been mentioned yet: "über jemanden urteilen". This is also, in my opinion, the most natural translation for "don't judge me", which then becomes "urteile nicht über mich". A Google search shows that this phrase appears to be quite widely used:

http://www.google.com/search?q=%22urteile+nicht+%C3%BCber+mich%22

In addition, "über jemanden urteilen" carries at least some of the Christian undertones that "to judge someone" has... enough at least that this Christian blog uses it in the title of one of its articles:

http://de.evangelist-online.net/kirche-gemeinde/urteile-nicht-uber-mich

In the body of the text, though, the article then goes on to use the verb "richten", which is certainly the usual translation of "judge" in the context of "judge not, that ye not be judged".

share|improve this answer

The English use of "Don't judge me!" covers many different contexts.

"Richten" does rarely have the same flavour. It would be used to translate related bible phrases on the theme of "don't judge others".

In the context of a relationship a closely-related phrase that is actually used often would be:

"Hör auf mir Vorwürfe zu machen."

(Literally: Stop making accusations against me.)

In the context "Walk a mile in my shoes before judging me.", people would rather say:

"Wenn du jemals in meiner Situation gewesen wärst, würdest du anders reden."

(If you would ever have been in my situation, you would talk differently.)

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.