Skip to main content
added 654 characters in body
Source Link
amadeusamadeus
  • 7.8k
  • 20
  • 43

As you say, the question pronoun corresponding to

Ich komme nicht auf das Netzwerklaufwerk

is wohin, so it's rather a determination of the direction than of location. This makes the difference because the prepositions

an, auf, hinter, in, neben, über, unter, vor, zwischen

are called Wechselpräposition and can govern either the dative or the accusative, changing their meaning. When they describe a location (as in auf dem Netzlaufwerk speichern – wo?), they govern the dative. If they are used to indicate a location (auf das Netzlaufwerk kommen – wohin?), they go with the accusative.

As a native speaker, you will intuitively understand the difference between Ich gehe auf dem Boot (dative) and Ich gehe auf das Boot (accusative).* You might also have heard the verb kommen getting an insinuating meaning when used with a Wechselpräposition governing the dative (see no. 17 here): Ich komme auf das Sofa (accusative, direction, standard meaning) vs. Ich komme auf dem Sofa (dative, location, insinuating meaning).


*This example is similar to tofro's, but better comparable to the original sentences because it's neuter as well and hence uses the same articles.

As you say, the question pronoun corresponding to

Ich komme nicht auf das Netzwerklaufwerk

is wohin, so it's rather a determination of the direction than of location. This makes the difference because the prepositions

an, auf, hinter, in, neben, über, unter, vor, zwischen

are called Wechselpräposition and can govern either the dative or the accusative, changing their meaning. When they describe a location (as in auf dem Netzlaufwerk speichern – wo?), they govern the dative. If they are used to indicate a location (auf das Netzlaufwerk kommen – wohin?), they go with the accusative.

As you say, the question pronoun corresponding to

Ich komme nicht auf das Netzwerklaufwerk

is wohin, so it's rather a determination of the direction than of location. This makes the difference because the prepositions

an, auf, hinter, in, neben, über, unter, vor, zwischen

are called Wechselpräposition and can govern either the dative or the accusative, changing their meaning. When they describe a location (as in auf dem Netzlaufwerk speichern – wo?), they govern the dative. If they are used to indicate a location (auf das Netzlaufwerk kommen – wohin?), they go with the accusative.

As a native speaker, you will intuitively understand the difference between Ich gehe auf dem Boot (dative) and Ich gehe auf das Boot (accusative).* You might also have heard the verb kommen getting an insinuating meaning when used with a Wechselpräposition governing the dative (see no. 17 here): Ich komme auf das Sofa (accusative, direction, standard meaning) vs. Ich komme auf dem Sofa (dative, location, insinuating meaning).


*This example is similar to tofro's, but better comparable to the original sentences because it's neuter as well and hence uses the same articles.

added 185 characters in body
Source Link
amadeusamadeus
  • 7.8k
  • 20
  • 43

As you say, the question pronoun corresponding to

Ich komme nicht auf das Netzwerklaufwerk

is wohin, so it's rather a determination of the direction than of location. This makes the difference because the prepositions

an, auf, hinter, in, neben, über, unter, vor, zwischen

are called Wechselpräposition. Whether they govern and can (~ require; trigger)govern either the dative or the accusative depends on whether, changing their meaning. When they describe a location (dativeas in auf dem Netzlaufwerk speichern – wo?) or, they govern the dative. If they are used to indicate a directionlocation (accusativeauf das Netzlaufwerk kommen – wohin?), they go with the accusative.

As you say, the question pronoun corresponding to

Ich komme nicht auf das Netzwerklaufwerk

is wohin, so it's rather a determination of the direction than of location. This makes the difference because the prepositions

an, auf, hinter, in, neben, über, unter, vor, zwischen

are called Wechselpräposition. Whether they govern (~ require; trigger) the dative or the accusative depends on whether they describe a location (dative) or a direction (accusative).

As you say, the question pronoun corresponding to

Ich komme nicht auf das Netzwerklaufwerk

is wohin, so it's rather a determination of the direction than of location. This makes the difference because the prepositions

an, auf, hinter, in, neben, über, unter, vor, zwischen

are called Wechselpräposition and can govern either the dative or the accusative, changing their meaning. When they describe a location (as in auf dem Netzlaufwerk speichern – wo?), they govern the dative. If they are used to indicate a location (auf das Netzlaufwerk kommen – wohin?), they go with the accusative.

Source Link
amadeusamadeus
  • 7.8k
  • 20
  • 43

As you say, the question pronoun corresponding to

Ich komme nicht auf das Netzwerklaufwerk

is wohin, so it's rather a determination of the direction than of location. This makes the difference because the prepositions

an, auf, hinter, in, neben, über, unter, vor, zwischen

are called Wechselpräposition. Whether they govern (~ require; trigger) the dative or the accusative depends on whether they describe a location (dative) or a direction (accusative).