1

As far I know we normally form the conjunctive II with the preterite (past) form of the verb. Coming from the preterite, we replace a with ä, u with ü and o with ö and also add an extra e if possible. For example:

  1. gehen – gingen – sind gegangen.
    Präteritum: Ich ging
    Konjuktiv II: Ich ginge

  2. arbeiten – arbeiteten – haben gearbeitet
    Präteritum: Ich arbeitete
    Konjuktiv II : Ich arbeitete (as there is no a, o, u to replace and it has already got an e at the end)

According to this rule besuchen and machen should be conjugated as following:

  1. besuchen – besuchten – haben besucht
    Präteritum: Ich besuchte
    Konjuktiv II: Ich besüchte – which seems to be wrong; the correct conjugation is besuchte.

  2. machen – machten – haben gemacht
    Präteritum: Ich machte
    Konjuktiv II: Ich mächte – wrong, correct conjugation is machte.

Could anyone please explain why are we not replacing u with ü in besuchen and a with ä in machen?

  • 2
    @Carsten Schulz: The allophones of -ch- are not an issue. Consider brechen, brach, bräche, gebrochen; or kriechen, kroch, kröche, gekrochen. – chirlu May 29 '15 at 15:48
  • @Thanks. I was looking for examples in my head, but did not find any. – Carsten S May 29 '15 at 15:51
6

The rule you cited only applies to strong verbs (also called irregular verbs):

lesen: las, läse
biegen: bog, böge
schaffen: schuf, schüfe
laufen: lief, liefe

It is not applicable to weak verbs (regular verbs), which form the past tenses with -t-. For them, the Konjunktiv II is normally identical to the Präteritum:

machen: machte, machte
besuchen: besuchte, besuchte

(Note that the rule does not cover all cases of strong verbs, either; e.g., sterben has forms starb and stürbe.)

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Although one might argue that stürbe is nothing else than an ‘even stronger’ umlaut ;) – Jan May 29 '15 at 16:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.