1

It is said that sich freuen über etwas applies to something that has come to existence while sich freuen auf etwas applies to something that is yet to become ;

I am wondering whether this division of labour is carried on into the usage of the noun Freude :
does Freude über etwas applies to sth. that has existed while Freude auf etwas applies to sth. that hasn't yet come to existence?

I read the following sentence from a book (CONTRAST by Elisabeth Rudolph) :
,,Er vermutete ein Anliegen und empfand eine gewisse ängstliche Freude darüber ;
doch sprach sie vorläufig nur schöne Worte.''
To me, the phrase Freude darüber should be better substituted with Freude darauf, because he took delight over rather his supposition, which has not yet come true, than an Actual situation. Would any one agree or disagree to this point?

  • 2
    Freude auf etwas isn’t used at all. It’s not too rare that use of prepositions differs between related verb and noun; another common example is sich interessieren für etwas vs. Interesse an etwas. – chirlu May 3 '16 at 10:28
  • You can sich auf etwas freuen, but you rarely use the term Ich empfinde Freude auf .... You might want to say Ich empfinde Vorfreude auf [z.b. die Ferien, meinen Feierabend, etc.], but most of the time you'll say ich freue mich auf .... – Thorsten Dittmar May 3 '16 at 14:28
2

I would disagree.

He thinks theres an "Anliegen", and he's glad because of that. (Er freut sich ÜBER das Anliegen (which he thinks there would be))

The other possibility would be, he KNOWS theres an "Anliegen", and he can't await to hear it. (Er freut sich AUF das Anliegen)

| improve this answer | |
  • With what do you disagree? – Robert May 5 '16 at 18:36
  • Lynnnyo wrote: "Would any one agree or disagree to this point?" at the end of his question, I said I disagree with this point. Read the question to find out what point I disagree with ;) – R3IN3K3 May 10 '16 at 8:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.