2

Would this not be a passive construction?
Full context from Eine kurze Geschichte der Zeit by Stephen Hawking:

Im Falle des Merkur jedoch, der – von allen Planeten der Sonne am nächsten – der stärksten Gravitationswirkung unterworfen ist und eine entsprechend längliche Umlaufbahn hat, prognostiziert die allgemeine Relativitätstheorie, daß die lange Achse der Ellipse sich mit einer Geschwindigkeit von ungefähr einem Grad pro zehntausend Jahren um die Sonne drehen müßte.

4

I don't like the German translation and would choose instead:

der stärksten Gravitationswirkung unterliegt

Unterwerfen has a strong action connotation, which is not appropriate here, and which is also part of the reason, why unterworfen wird is not a good choice here.

Nobody does anything to expose Mercure to gravitation, it is simply a state (applicable since Mercure exists), why Zustandpassiv (and therefore unterworfen ist) is a convincing grammatical choice.

  • That's right, I sometimes get confused after switching between languages for a long time and forgot that construction exists in German. – user5389726598465 Mar 17 '17 at 11:05
  • This does not answer the question of whether it should be werden or sein. – Jan Mar 18 '17 at 14:59
4

German has two different types of passive voice:

  • Zustandspassiv (stative passive)
  • Vorgangspassiv (dynamic passive)

I show you with shorter sentences:

Zustandspassiv

Der Planet ist der Schwerkraft unterworfen.
The planet is subject to gravity.

This is the description of a state (state = Zustand in German). Nothing is happening here. This is just the description of how it is.

Vorgangspassiv

Der Planet wird der Schwerkraft unterworfen.
The planet is subjected to gravity.

This is the description of an process (process = Vorgang). Here we are watching how something is changing. The planet was not subjected to gravity in the past, but it will be in the future, and now this change is going on.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.