3

It seems that the latter is the right one. But, the former one is more reasonably by grammar?

Anyway, it should be a noun.

  • 4
    You could easily look up this by entering "recht haben Duden" in your preferred search engine. - According to "Duden", both spellings (capital letter vs. small letter) are acceptable but recommended is "recht haben". This is also how it was obligatorily spelled previous to the so called Rechtschreibreform in the mid 1990. The traditional spellings - which still are considered better by some - had developped over centuries as good practice in professional typesetting. There must not always be a "logical" explanation. – Christian Geiselmann May 8 '17 at 7:49
2

Both versions are correct, but there is a subtile difference in Meaning. So subtile, that most speakers are not aware of it, but I'll show you:

Du hast Recht.

Here »Recht« is a noun, that you also could use with an article, but this is not usual in German:

Du hast (das) Recht.
You have (the) right.

But in ...

Du hast recht.

The word recht is an adjective in adverbial usage. Like almost all adjectives, you can use this adjective:

  • attributive

    Mach weiter so, du bist auf dem rechten Weg.
    Go on, you are on the right way.

  • predicative

    Es war nicht recht, ihn fortzujagen.
    It was not right to chase him away.

  • adverbial

    Du hast recht.
    You are right.


The recommended version is the lowercase version: »Du hast recht.« But both versions are correct.

  • Doch man kann sagen, Du hast (das) Recht, hier zu kommen. Ja? – ΥΣΕΡ26328 May 8 '17 at 10:25
  • 1
    @User26328: Ja, das kann man so sagen. Aber Vorsicht! »Du hast das Recht, hier zu kommen« bedeutet: »Du hast das Recht, hier einen Orgasmus zu haben.« Du meinst vermutlich: »Du hast das Recht, hierher zu kommen«. (»hier kommen« = to have an orgasm here. »hierher kommen« = to come here.) In der deutschen Sprache darf man Orte und Richtungen nicht verwechseln! – Hubert Schölnast May 8 '17 at 16:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.