German Language Stack Exchange is a bilingual question and answer site for speakers of all levels who want to share and increase their knowledge of the German language. It's 100% free, no registration required.
Sign up to join this community
Can a German sentence take more than one subject? I saw this as an example sentence on the German Wiktionary page for Vorgang:
Die Wahrnehmung von Gerüchen ist ein komplexer Vorgang.
Are Die Wahrnehmung von Gerüchen and ein komplexer Vorgang not each subjects? They are both in the nominative case.
Short answer:
Long answer:
These are the parts of this sentence:
The predicate consists of two parts:
Other names for Gleichsetzungsnominativ are:
You also will find the name Nominativobjekt, but as said before, it is not an object, it is part of the predicate.
Copulas are special verbs, that do not really describe an action. They have a grammatical function. They link (couple) something together. Examples of copulas are:
But there are also some more.
Those verbs only can be used with a Prädikativ (predicative supplement) which either is a nominal group in nominative case (which always contains a noun in nominative case) or an adjective group (which always contains an adjective).
Examples:
just a noun (nominal group with nothing else but the noun)
Markus wird Lehrer.
Markus becomes a teacher.
Laura ist Italienerin.
Laura is Italian.
Ich heiße Hubert.
I am called Hubert.
nominal group
Heute wird ein schöner Tag.
Today will be a nice day.
Frau Steiner bleibt eine meiner liebsten Lehrerinnen.
Mrs. Steiner remains one of my favorite teachers.
Die Wahrnehmung von Gerüchen ist ein komplexer Vorgang.
The perception of smells is a complex process.
just an adjective
Der Garten von Thomas ist schön.
Thomas's garden is beautiful.
adjective group
Herr Müller ist alles andere als erfreut.
Mr. Müller is anything but pleased.
How to tell apart the subject and the predicative nominative?
There are German sentences where it is ambiguous which part of speech should count as the subject. You surely know that in German the subject has no fix place in a sentence. It can be (almost) everythere, but normally it is easy to find, because normally it is the only part of speech that is in nominative case.
Here is an example:
The hunter shoots the rabbit.
In English the hunter and the rabbit are both in nominative case, but this doesn't matter, because in English the subject is the first part of the sentence. You clearly know who is pulling the trigger (the hunter) and who will die (the rabbit). This would be wrong in English:
wrong: The rabbit shoots the hunter.
But in German these two sentences are both absolutely correct:
Der Jäger erschießt den Hasen.
Den Hasen erschießt der Jäger.
In German it is not the position but the grammatical case which indicates the subject. Here, in both sentences der Jäger is the only part of speech in nominative case, so it is very clear, that der Jäger must be the subject (the one who pulls the trigger) and that den Hasen (something in accusative case) must be something else (here it is an accusative object).
But then there are sentences like this one:
Marillen sind Aprikosen.
Both nouns are perfect synonyms. They are both names for the very same fruit (apricots), just with different geographical extension (The word Marille is used in Austria, Italy (South Tyrol) and parts of Bavaria, Aprikose is used everywhere else).
Which one is the subject, and which one is the predicative nominative?
In this example you simply can't tell. Both interpretations are correct, and both interpretations match with the same meaning. (which is: They are equal)
But in some other cases you can tell them apart:
Bäume sind Pflanzen.
Every tree is a plant, but there are plants who are not trees. Here it is clear, that Bäume is the subject and sind Pflanzen is the predicate.
Another test is the infinitive test: Turn the verb into its infinite form and try to match it with what you believe might be the predicative nominative. The result that makes more sense indicates the predicative nominative:
Markus ist ein kluges Kind. (Markus is a clever child.)
Trying to be a clever child makes more sense than trying to be Markus, so ein kluges Kind is the predicative nominative and Markus is the subject.
Marillen sind Aprikosen.
Both possibilities make the same amount of sense (because they both mean exactly the same: to be apricots), so you can't tell which one is the subject.
