0

Bis zu ihrem Abschluss in Psychologie möchte Andrea nicht umziehen.

Why ihrem after akkusative bis?

  • In what way do you consider bis an accusative preposition? It's not, it takes complements either without overt case markers ("bis bald") or governed by a construction other than the "bis" ("bis nächsten Montag" - temporal accusative; "bis zum Wahnsinn" - dative governed by "zu"). – Kilian Foth Apr 14 at 5:42
6

Bis is always an accusative preposition. Here the preposition that governs the case is zu (an always-dative preposition), that is why you have ihrem instead of ihren.

  • Good explanation, that was the piece I'm missing. – stephanmg Apr 13 at 18:59
  • Thanks for filling the gap c.p. – stephanmg Apr 13 at 19:40
2

The preposition "bis" can be used with the german Akkusativ and Dativ as well. Usually "bis" with Akkusativ but if you use "bis zu" then the Dativ may follow (Temporal preposition).

Usually one can omit the "zu" when using "bis zu" and it seems "bis" would required always Dativ which is not true. You can find and construct a variety of sentences using either of the casi.

Best wishes, SG

  • 1
    Thanks. Strange that this sentence used as an example of the accusative case here:deutsch-als-fremdsprache-lernen.de/… – Vladimir Nabokov Apr 13 at 18:21
  • Well, I don't know about this website or can give you a more rigorous grammatical explanation, however what I stated is usually true. Maybe somebody else can chime in? – stephanmg Apr 13 at 18:28
  • 1
    I just wonder why they used this sentence (which is akkusative + dative) in the plain accusative example...thanks. – Vladimir Nabokov Apr 13 at 18:38
  • Bis cannot be used with dative, so the first sentence is missleading. – c.p. Apr 13 at 18:43
  • 1
    @stephanmg Indeed – c.p. Apr 13 at 20:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.