4

When do you use von and when do you use a double-nominative construction, such as discussed at this linked question, when talking about the amount of something? Compare, for example,

ein Glas Wasser

and

tausende von Büchern

  • 2
    There is also an archaic construct "Ein Kästchen von Ebenholz" - where "von" was used in the sense of "aus" – tofro Apr 25 at 12:07
  • Compare English: thousands of books, a group of people, but one glass of water? – yunzen Apr 25 at 14:22
9

The von construction can be used with indefinite number adjectives, such as but not limited to "dutzende, hunderte, tausende, ...". But it is optional.

Thus, both sentences are grammatically correct and used:

Es wurden tausende Bücher verbrannt.

Es wurden tausende von Büchern verbrannt.

The latter construction puts more emphasis on the number.

Saying "Ich möchte ein Glas von Wasser" would be ungrammatical, because here you have a definite amount of glasses, namely 1.

2

This is a Partitive Apposition, see Canoo.net. It is just specification of an amount. Similarly constructed are drei Liter Wasser, 100g Mehl.

  • Okay, can your examples be phrased with von as well?? – Wilson Apr 25 at 13:59
  • No, it's a specific amount. – infinitezero Apr 25 at 17:43

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.