3

This change always bothered me. Is there a rule in German that prevents book titles from starting with an indefinite article?

  • 5
    Weil es falsch übersetzt wurde. – user unknown Jun 23 at 22:11
  • 5
    Believe it or not, but book titles are tuned so they get a prominent place in the shelves of the book shop. A Song … is perfect, it's in the leftmost shelf column. Das … is right at the start of the D column while Ein … is somewhere in the middle of the E column. Not so nice. So that change may be a publishers' requirement. – Janka Jun 23 at 23:03
  • 2
    Currently your post asks two different questions in title and body? Which one is it, you are actually asking? I'd also notice that the question in the title can't be answered by us for certain. We can only speculate about the translators/publishers motives. – Arsak Jun 24 at 6:25
  • 2
    this is quite a small change, compare it to sth bigger... "The Return of the First Avenger (Originaltitel: Captain America: The Winter Soldier)" or like "Thor – The Dark Kingdom (Originaltitel: Thor: The Dark World)" ... where I might miss the detail what a World is in english if I need a Königreich in german... – Shegit Brahm Jun 24 at 8:02
  • 3
    @userunknown Das ist mit Sicherheit keine "falsche" Übersetzung, sondern eine bewusst gewählte Übertragung. – jonathan.scholbach Jun 24 at 19:35
4

That's a tricky one and we can only speculate why it was done.

However, we can say for sure, that there is no such rule. But there are far less (fantasy) book titles starting with an indefinite article than with a definitive one.

For your question, we have to go back to 1997, as this was the year when "A Game of Thrones" was first published in Germany. The book was split in two and published in 1997 as "Die Herren von Winterfell" and the 2nd part in 1998 as "Das Erbe von Winterfell". Follow this link to get the creeps from looking at the covers (I'm not sure about image copyrights, so I won't embed them here).

You can see: the series was already called "Das Lied von Eis und Feuer". So ... why?

From my point of view:

It sounds far better to call it "Das Lied von Eis und Feuer" than "Ein Lied von Eis und Feuer"

Choosing a title and a cover is a lot about psychology and when you look at the cover of the 2nd book, oh boy ... is that Conan the barbarian? I'm pretty sure they used this image, so everybody knows: FANTASY!!!11

"Ein Lied" sounds vague, dull, boring. But "Das Lied" sounds like I want to hear that one song. Or I want to know what this is about.


I also don't think it has very much to do with how books are sorted at the store. When looking at the books published from 1995-2000 containg der, die or das vs ein I would rather publish one starting with "ein", because there is much less competition in the e-section. (I know, the search results are not 100% accurate, but you get the point).

Maybe it's a translation error. But I don't think that either. Just look: There are tons of books in German, which are named nothing like the original. Just compare "Ein ganzes halbes Jahr" and "Me Before You".

Maybe they just didn't "care" and as @Annatar said in the comments it's much easier to come up with generic "Der/die/das X von Y" titles compared to the more poetic "Ein Spiel der Throne".

  • 1
    +1 for the link to the original German covers. I disagree that "ein Lied"/"a song" sounds more dull or boring than "Das Lied"/"The song" though. It is slightly unusual, but this might as well make it more interesting. – Annatar Jun 24 at 11:36
  • If you ask me, they simply didn't invest significant time for "just another run-of-the-mill fantasy series", and it's much easier to come up with generic "Der/die/das X von Y" titles compared to the more poetic "Ein Spiel der Throne" etc. (especially when you have to name twice the number of books). – Annatar Jun 24 at 11:50
  • 2
    Compare "Möchtest du ein Lied von Eis und Feuer hören?" vs "Möchtest du das Lied von Eis und Feuer hören?" The first one is not really exciting. Well, it's just a song about it. The second example is way more "man, it is THE song", so I agree with @mtwde that it could be about psychology – infinitezero Jun 24 at 15:22
  • 2
    Stripes, Meatballs, Airplane. That business is at times not translating at all but merely corrupting words. – LаngLаngС Jun 24 at 15:59
3

There's no rule that a book title has to be translated literally. It's the normal case, but the publisher, author or anyone else involved may think that another name would be better. Placement in the book shelf is just one reason.

In my opinion, "Das Lied ..." sounds much better than "Ein Lied ...". Others have said it sounds dull or boring. Why?

  • If you say "Ein Lied" it's only claim is that it is one among many. There may be hundreds of songs about other and the same topic, whereas "Das Lied" means that it is outstanding: it's the only or at least the "definite" book.

  • Often subtitles start with "Ein". A title like "Die Westeros-Saga - Ein Lied von Eis und Feuer" would have been a very conventional name for a series of fantasy novels. In the worst case, I might think that the author couldn't think of a good title for his book and finally used his subtitle. If the creativity of an author is not even sufficient for a good title, why should the content be worthwhile?

  • 1
    Thanks for the answer. I love how this question evolved into a discussion about authors and publishers. This makes me wonder though... Why does the original title with the indefinite article, "A/Ein", sound dull in German and not in English? That's an interesting question I think – Ahmad Labib Mansour Jun 26 at 8:04
  • interesting question indeed – tjb Jun 27 at 13:49
  • I just searched my feelings, and I think "A song of Ice and Fire" would feel the same as "Lied von Eis und Feuer" or "Eis und Feuers Lied"... The focus is more on the Ice and Fire, and not so much on the song. – Lichtbringer Jun 29 at 12:30
  • On the other hand, maybe it's just a convention that has been reinforced over time by repeated use. And now it looks weird to us in that form, because we are just used to the other one. – Lichtbringer Jun 29 at 12:36
1

There's no such rule in German that prevents book titles from starting with an indefinite article. It's just artistic freedom of the translator. It happens very often titles are differently translated than a 1:1 translation. It's for marketing reasons or considers cultural aspects of the target country. No obvious reason is given in your example.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.