I'm aware German doesn't have a gerund like the English language does, so I was just wondering how you could translate "being a" as in "being a vegetarian may cause health problems"?
Would "als" work here?
-
3being -> to be -> zu sein – Em1 Dec 6 '12 at 21:39
-
2Just for clarification, German does have a Gerund form by making the verb a neuter noun: "sein" ("be") to "das Sein" ("the action of being something or existing"), just for the example here. – Kevin Dec 7 '12 at 5:27
-
@ em1: you are missing the cause-notion of "being a" – Emanuel Dec 7 '12 at 22:33
As @Em1 correctly explained
Vegetarier zu sein könnte gesundheitliche Probleme verursachen/ bedingen.
oder flüssiger
Vegetarier zu sein könnte der Gesundheit abträglich sein / schaden.
-
These examples are grammatically correct but unidiomatic. Germans don't typically use "zu sein" gerunds. Active verbs sound better: I'd try "Sich an eine vegetarische Diät zu halten..." or "Als Vegetarier zu leben..." . – Andrew Cone Dec 8 '12 at 1:20
-
3I disagree in so far as that your examples are not any better or more common. On the contrary , to me they are more complicated the one of Bummie... If someone wanted to match the succinctness of the English gerund, a German would probably say "Eine vegetarische Ernährung kann zu ... " or more colloquial "Kein Fleisch zu essen... – Emanuel Dec 8 '12 at 20:11
-
As a native speaker, I don't think the use of "zu sein" is unidiomatic. However, I don't like the „könnte“. I would probably use "Vegetarier zu sein kann der Gesundheit schaden." or "Vegetarier zu sein kann zu gesundheitlichen Problemen führen." – cfaerber Dec 8 '12 at 23:39
-
Noch kompakter: "Vegetarismus kann der Gesundheit schaden" o. "~ kann ungesund sein". Vor allem schmeckt es nicht. ;) – user unknown Dec 9 '12 at 1:11
-
In your example "being a vegetarian may cause health problems," you'd need to resort to a different expression, e.g. change the phrase "being a vegetarian" to "to live as a vegetarian" or "life as a vegetarian":
a) |Als Vegetarier zu leben| verursacht möglicherweise Gesundheitsprobleme.
b) |Das Leben als Vegetarier| ruft möglicherweise Gesundheitsprobleme hervor.
It's a different thing with e.g. "being a chef, he knew how to make lasagna," where you can indeed use "Als X":
|Als Koch| wusste er, wie man Lasagne zubereitet.
-
+1 for the difference between "being a vegetarian" and "being a chef" (or rather the significance of the comma). – Hagen von Eitzen Dec 7 '12 at 21:31
-
we can bring the examples even closer together: "Being a vegetarian he knows how to cook tasty stuff with vegetables"... there are different functions of "being a" – Emanuel Dec 7 '12 at 22:31
Additionally als can be used as you actually purposed.
For instance
Being an office employee, I don't dare to complain about that.
could be like so
Als Büroangestellter wage ich nicht mich darüber zu beschweren.
-
-
@CarstenSchultz right. What I had in mind is the more general question in the title. – user5513 Feb 26 '14 at 1:09
