3

The grammar says that a German vowel is long if it is followed by a single consonant. So I think this word * Ökologie* should be pronounced as /ø ː ko ː lo ː ɡiː/, because every vowel in it is followed by a single consonant. But in wiktionary its pronunciation is /økoloˈɡiː/. So is it true that only accented vowels will be pronounced long?

3
  • 3
    Pronounciation rules frequently don't apply to loanwords (here a loanword from Greek). However, I would say all vowels in "Ökologie" are long.
    – Roland
    Aug 15 at 9:28
  • 1
    It sounds to me that your grammar has confused phonology (vowel length) with orthography (single or double letters).
    – fdb
    Aug 15 at 10:32
  • It is kindof pointless to ask for "words with several ..." in German, because we have compound words. "Radfahren", "Fahrradfahranfänger",.... all have several long vowels.
    – tofro
    Aug 15 at 14:47

3 Answers 3

6

Vowels such as /o/, /ø/ or /i/ are called long or tense and stand in opposition to /ɔ/, /œ/, /ɪ/, which are called short or lax.* As the chosen IPA symbols indicate, these phonemes differ by quality. Only the (phonemically) long or tense vowels can be realised as phonetically long, i.e. /o/ can be realised as [oː], but /ɔ/ cannot be realised as [ɔː]. Therefore, Ökologie is a word with three (phonemically) long vowels, although only the stressed vowel is realised as phonetically long.

As you surmised, long or tense vowel phonemes will typically be realised as phonetically long in stressed syllables. Compare the difference between Ökologie [økoloˈgiː] and Öko [ˈøːko], the latter with stress on the first syllable and /ø/ realised as [øː] where the former has [ø] (the base for both is /øko/).

With regard to the rule your grammar gave, it presumably wanted to hint at the contexts in which (phonemically) long or tense vowels occur. For certain examples, the rule might work: O-fen has /o/, of-fen has /ɔ/. For others, it might not: von has /ɔ/, lobt has /o/. That is, in reality it's much more complicated.

One further complication: German allows reductions of long or tense vowels to short or lax vowels (with speakers differing widely in their judgements as to what is admissible in the standard language). For instance, I'm pretty sure that I often pronounce Ökologie as [œkɔlɔgˈiː]. These reductions can become phonemic: Politik can be /-ˈtik/ as well as /-ˈtɪk/.

See also List of words that demonstrate all German consonant and vowel sounds.

* Some phonologists prefer the opposition long vs. short, others tense vs. lax. The important thing is that one binary feature suffices.

4

This rule is true for Erbwörter (sorry, I don't know the english term. Maybe "inherited words"?). These are words that are part of German language since it started to exist (how ever you define that date), like Wasser, Vater, reiten, gehen, ...

Erbwörter usually have two syllables. The first syllable is stressed, the second is unstressed. But there are also Erbwörter with only one syllable (der, ich, es, nicht, Hand, Fuß, ...)

The rule that two or more consonants at the end of a syllable indicate a short vowel while all other vowels are long holds only for Erbwörter with two syllables. But even monosyllabic Erbwörter have so many exceptions, that it's hard to tell if this rule even applies for them.

And there is no reason why other languages than German should follow German grammar rules. So, it makes no sense to apply this rules to foreign words and to loan words.

1
  • 1
    May i nitpickingly note that even not German must follow German grammar rules, as in natural languages grammar rules (in the book) are derived from real-world usage, not the other way round. (When deviations are observed, the grammer-rule-book writers add sub-paragraphs to list exceptions and thus make them part of the rule.) Sep 14 at 10:46
3

As @Roland already said in his comment "Ökologie" is a greek loan word. The greek language has two different kinds of "o", the "small o" and the "large o": omikron ("Ο" "ο") and omega ("Ω" "ω").

The "ö" in "Öko" is originally written with "οι" (omicron, iota) and a diphtong, whereas the second "o" is an "ο" (omicron). Because for diphtongs there are different rules the first vowel is pronounced long, because the second vowel is an omicron its pronounciation is impliedly short.

PS: notice, that "omicron" and "omega" are names given to these vowels only in byzantinian times, when both "o"-sounds where pronounced the same way. In classical times they were pronounced [⁠oː⁠]​ and [⁠ɔː⁠]​.

3
  • 1
    The Greek spelling (omikron or omega) has no bearing on the German pronunciation.
    – fdb
    Aug 15 at 10:35
  • 2
    The greek spelling may not, but the greek pronounciation probably does. And the greek pronounciation depends on the greek spelling.
    – bakunin
    Aug 15 at 10:38
  • 1
    O-micron = small (short) O. O-mega = large (long) O Aug 15 at 10:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.