In my current translation project I have the phrase "there appears to be something lying in a heap," referring to a rope ladder which is sitting on the ground at a certain point in an underground tunnel. Rather than being laid out straight along the ground, is it positioned like a pile of leaves.

Google Translate gives me "auf einem Haufen liegen" for "lying in a heap," but this is the same as "lying on a heap," or "lying on a pile," which is not what I am trying to say. The rope ladder is the heap; it is not on top of anything else. I am also not sure about "in einem Haufen liegen" since it is not actually in anything.

I can think of ways to convey the literal meaning such as "haufenartig" or "in Haufenform" but I am not sure this is colloquially normal language. Please advise!

2 Answers 2


There appears to be something lying in a heap.

Yeah, no. You can't say auf einem Haufen for in a heap of single things. Only for a multiple things. For single things, it always means on a heap (of other things). So you have to rephrase, e.g.

Da scheint irgendwas hingeschmissen worden zu sein.

That conveys that it's a single item but also a mess. But German speakers would likely just say

Da scheint irgendwas herumzuliegen.

as that verb herumliegen exists for that particular purpose.


Example: A couple of humans stumbled and fell over - now, in German, you say: They are lying on a heap.

Die Menschen liegen auf einem Haufen.

Which is of course ambiguous, but you get the right meaning from context.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.