Return to Question

The following sentence was said by RAF member Gudrun Ensslin (in 1968, I believe):

Ich hab den Richtern gesagt, 'ich weiß, warum sie sagen, man kann nichts tun, weil sie nichts tun können wollen, aber ich will etwas getan haben dagegen'.

I'm surprised/puzzled by the fact that the sentence does not end with the verb (haben), and instead ends with dagegen.

Compounding my confusing is an uncertainty over what the da in dagegen (if I may parse it this way) is referring to. I can think of two very different possibilities:

1. da = what "they" (sie) had said about not being able to act (i.e. Ensslin is contrasting her position/attitude towards the possibility of action against "theirs"); or
2. da = whatever world condition/situation compelled Ensslin to take action.

Would it be ungrammatical to say

1. "aber ich will dagegen etwas getan haben"?
2. "aber ich will etwas dagegen getan haben"? Or

(I've keyed the last two options to correspond to the two alternative interpretations I gave just before.)

The following sentence was said by RAF member Gudrun Ensslin (1968):

Ich hab den Richtern gesagt, 'ich weiß, warum sie sagen, man kann nichts tun, weil sie nichts tun können wollen, aber ich will etwas getan haben dagegen'.

(For more context, see this page; the text I've quoted appears in the fifth paragraph.)

I'm surprised/puzzled by the fact that the sentence does not end with the verb (haben), and instead ends with dagegen.

Compounding my confusion is an uncertainty over what the da in dagegen (if I may parse it this way) is referring to. I can think of two very different possibilities:

1. da = what "they" (sie) had said about not being able to act (i.e. Ensslin is contrasting her position/attitude towards the possibility of action against "theirs"); or
2. da = whatever world condition/situation compelled Ensslin to take action.

Would it be ungrammatical to say

1. "aber ich will dagegen etwas getan haben"?
2. "aber ich will etwas dagegen getan haben"? Or

(I've keyed the last two options to correspond to the two alternative interpretations I gave just before.)

The following sentence was said by RAF member Gudrun Ensslin (in 1968, I believe):

Ich hab den Richtern gesagt, 'ich weiß, warum sie sagen, man kann nichts tun, weil sie nichts tun können wollen, aber ich will etwas getan haben dagegen'.

I'm surprised/puzzled that the sentence does not end with the verb (haben), and instead ends in dagegen.

Compounding my confusing is an uncertainty over whether the da in dagegen (if I may parse it this way) is referring to

1. what "they" (sie) had said (i.e. Ensslin is contrasting her position/attitude against "theirs"); or to
2. whatever world condition/situation Ensslin felt compelled to do something about.

Would it be ungrammatical to say

1. "aber ich will dagegen etwas getan haben"?
2. "aber ich will etwas dagegen getan haben"? Or

(I've keyed the last two options to correspond to the two alternative interpretations I gave just before.)

The following sentence was said by RAF member Gudrun Ensslin (in 1968, I believe):

Ich hab den Richtern gesagt, 'ich weiß, warum sie sagen, man kann nichts tun, weil sie nichts tun können wollen, aber ich will etwas getan haben dagegen'.

I'm surprised/puzzled by the fact that the sentence does not end with the verb (haben), and instead ends with dagegen.

Compounding my confusing is an uncertainty over what the da in dagegen (if I may parse it this way) is referring to. I can think of two very different possibilities:

1. da = what "they" (sie) had said about not being able to act (i.e. Ensslin is contrasting her position/attitude towards the possibility of action against "theirs"); or
2. da = whatever world condition/situation compelled Ensslin to take action.

Would it be ungrammatical to say

1. "aber ich will dagegen etwas getan haben"?
2. "aber ich will etwas dagegen getan haben"? Or

(I've keyed the last two options to correspond to the two alternative interpretations I gave just before.)

The following sentence was said by RAF member Gudrun Ensslin (in 1968, I believe):

Ich hab den Richtern gesagt, 'ich weiß, warum sie sagen, man kann nichts tun, weil sie nichts tun können wollen, aber ich will etwas getan haben dagegen'.

I'm surprised/puzzled that the sentence does not end with the verb (haben), and instead ends in dagegen.

Compounding my confusing is my uncertainty over whether the da in dagegen (if I may parse it this way) is referring to

1. what "they" (sie) had said (i.e. Ensslin is contrasting her position against "theirs"); or to
2. whatever condition or situation in the world Ensslin felt compelled to do something about.

Would it be ungrammatical to say

1. "aber ich will etwas dagegen getan haben"? Or
2. "aber ich will dagegen etwas getan haben"?

(I've keyed the last two options to correspond to the two alternative interpretations I gave just before.)

The following sentence was said by RAF member Gudrun Ensslin (in 1968, I believe):

Ich hab den Richtern gesagt, 'ich weiß, warum sie sagen, man kann nichts tun, weil sie nichts tun können wollen, aber ich will etwas getan haben dagegen'.

I'm surprised/puzzled that the sentence does not end with the verb (haben), and instead ends in dagegen.

Compounding my confusing is an uncertainty over whether the da in dagegen (if I may parse it this way) is referring to

1. what "they" (sie) had said (i.e. Ensslin is contrasting her position/attitude against "theirs"); or to
2. whatever world condition/situation Ensslin felt compelled to do something about.

Would it be ungrammatical to say

1. "aber ich will dagegen etwas getan haben"?
2. "aber ich will etwas dagegen getan haben"? Or

(I've keyed the last two options to correspond to the two alternative interpretations I gave just before.)